{ "status": "published", "reportId": "north-american-msp-email-security-2026", "publishedAt": "2026-08-14T21:10:00.000Z", "generatedAt": "2026-08-14T20:45:10.371Z", "cohort": { "id": "north-american-msp-email-security-2026", "title": "North American MSP email-authentication benchmark 2026", "description": "Aggregate DNS measurements of MSP organizational domains listed on publicly indexed Clutch U.S. and Canada market pages.", "sourceName": "Clutch public MSP directory", "sourceUrl": "https://clutch.co/it-services/msp", "sourceDate": "2026-08-14", "sourceLicense": "Public factual discovery data; no directory copy republished", "sourceSnapshot": "950f20754010ce2d1cb61865a53a96bbcccddaf3bc5e1a196142d8900864a1e4", "restrictions": [ "Store only company name, market page, public size band, official website destination, and normalized domain.", "Do not collect descriptions, reviews, personal contacts, or marketing copy.", "Do not bypass Clutch access challenges; use only publicly indexed directory results and Visit Website destinations.", "Market-page appearance is not treated as headquarters evidence.", "Publish aggregate results only and never rank named MSPs." ], "createdAt": "2026-08-14T00:00:00.000Z", "updatedAt": "2026-08-14T20:45:02.258Z", "publicationPolicy": "aggregate_only", "minimumPublishableGroup": 30, "minimumCohortSize": 500, "requiredEntityCounts": { "msp": 500 } }, "methodology": { "totalInCorpus": 567, "observed": 566, "unobserved": 1, "observationFailureRate": { "count": 1, "of": 567, "pct": 0.2 }, "errorBreakdown": { "ESERVFAIL": 1 }, "spfDepthEnabled": true, "minimumPublishableGroup": 30, "suppressedGroups": 32, "scanStartedAt": "2026-08-14T20:45:02.938Z", "scanFinishedAt": "2026-08-14T20:45:07.494Z" }, "overall": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 504, "of": 566, "pct": 89 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 345, "of": 504, "pct": 68.5 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 84, "of": 504, "pct": 16.7 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 542, "of": 566, "pct": 95.8 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 5, "of": 566, "pct": 0.9 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 32, "of": 542, "pct": 5.9 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 23, "of": 566, "pct": 4.1 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 21, "of": 345, "pct": 6.1 }, "withMx": { "count": 549, "of": 566, "pct": 97 } }, "byDimension": { "country": [], "region": [ { "key": "Canada market", "label": "Canada market", "total": 30, "observed": 30, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 29, "of": 30, "pct": 96.7 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 22, "of": 29, "pct": 75.9 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 11, "of": 29, "pct": 37.9 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 30, "of": 30, "pct": 100 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 0, "of": 30, "pct": 0 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 2, "of": 30, "pct": 6.7 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 3, "of": 30, "pct": 10 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 3, "of": 22, "pct": 13.6 }, "withMx": { "count": 30, "of": 30, "pct": 100 } } }, { "key": "U.S. market", "label": "U.S. market", "total": 30, "observed": 30, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 26, "of": 30, "pct": 86.7 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 17, "of": 26, "pct": 65.4 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 4, "of": 26, "pct": 15.4 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 28, "of": 30, "pct": 93.3 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 0, "of": 30, "pct": 0 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 3, "of": 28, "pct": 10.7 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 1, "of": 30, "pct": 3.3 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 1, "of": 17, "pct": 5.9 }, "withMx": { "count": 28, "of": 30, "pct": 93.3 } } }, { "key": "San Francisco", "label": "San Francisco", "total": 26, "observed": 26, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Seattle", "label": "Seattle", "total": 25, "observed": 25, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Atlanta", "label": "Atlanta", "total": 24, "observed": 24, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Dallas", "label": "Dallas", "total": 24, "observed": 24, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Philadelphia", "label": "Philadelphia", "total": 24, "observed": 24, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Portland", "label": "Portland", "total": 24, "observed": 24, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Boston", "label": "Boston", "total": 22, "observed": 22, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Los Angeles", "label": "Los Angeles", "total": 22, "observed": 22, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "New York", "label": "New York", "total": 22, "observed": 22, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "San Diego", "label": "San Diego", "total": 22, "observed": 22, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Chicago", "label": "Chicago", "total": 21, "observed": 21, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Miami", "label": "Miami", "total": 22, "observed": 21, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Tampa", "label": "Tampa", "total": 21, "observed": 21, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Austin", "label": "Austin", "total": 20, "observed": 20, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Minneapolis", "label": "Minneapolis", "total": 20, "observed": 20, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Calgary", "label": "Calgary", "total": 19, "observed": 19, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Houston", "label": "Houston", "total": 17, "observed": 17, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Phoenix", "label": "Phoenix", "total": 17, "observed": 17, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Montreal", "label": "Montreal", "total": 16, "observed": 16, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Ottawa", "label": "Ottawa", "total": 16, "observed": 16, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Denver", "label": "Denver", "total": 14, "observed": 14, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Halifax", "label": "Halifax", "total": 14, "observed": 14, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Toronto", "label": "Toronto", "total": 14, "observed": 14, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Edmonton", "label": "Edmonton", "total": 13, "observed": 13, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Winnipeg", "label": "Winnipeg", "total": 12, "observed": 12, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Detroit", "label": "Detroit", "total": 9, "observed": 9, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "Saskatoon", "label": "Saskatoon", "total": 7, "observed": 7, "suppressed": true } ], "sector": [ { "key": "managed_service_provider", "label": "managed service provider", "total": 567, "observed": 566, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 504, "of": 566, "pct": 89 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 345, "of": 504, "pct": 68.5 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 84, "of": 504, "pct": 16.7 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 542, "of": 566, "pct": 95.8 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 5, "of": 566, "pct": 0.9 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 32, "of": 542, "pct": 5.9 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 23, "of": 566, "pct": 4.1 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 21, "of": 345, "pct": 6.1 }, "withMx": { "count": 549, "of": 566, "pct": 97 } } } ], "affiliation": [ { "key": "U.S. market", "label": "U.S. market", "total": 426, "observed": 425, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 383, "of": 425, "pct": 90.1 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 265, "of": 383, "pct": 69.2 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 61, "of": 383, "pct": 15.9 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 403, "of": 425, "pct": 94.8 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 5, "of": 425, "pct": 1.2 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 24, "of": 403, "pct": 6 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 16, "of": 425, "pct": 3.8 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 14, "of": 265, "pct": 5.3 }, "withMx": { "count": 410, "of": 425, "pct": 96.5 } } }, { "key": "Canada market", "label": "Canada market", "total": 141, "observed": 141, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 121, "of": 141, "pct": 85.8 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 80, "of": 121, "pct": 66.1 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 23, "of": 121, "pct": 19 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 139, "of": 141, "pct": 98.6 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 0, "of": 141, "pct": 0 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 8, "of": 139, "pct": 5.8 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 7, "of": 141, "pct": 5 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 7, "of": 80, "pct": 8.8 }, "withMx": { "count": 139, "of": 141, "pct": 98.6 } } } ], "entityType": [ { "key": "msp", "label": "msp", "total": 567, "observed": 566, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 504, "of": 566, "pct": 89 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 345, "of": 504, "pct": 68.5 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 84, "of": 504, "pct": 16.7 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 542, "of": 566, "pct": 95.8 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 5, "of": 566, "pct": 0.9 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 32, "of": 542, "pct": 5.9 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 23, "of": 566, "pct": 4.1 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 21, "of": 345, "pct": 6.1 }, "withMx": { "count": 549, "of": 566, "pct": 97 } } } ], "sizeBand": [ { "key": "10 - 49", "label": "10 - 49", "total": 243, "observed": 242, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 215, "of": 242, "pct": 88.8 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 140, "of": 215, "pct": 65.1 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 43, "of": 215, "pct": 20 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 231, "of": 242, "pct": 95.5 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 1, "of": 242, "pct": 0.4 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 16, "of": 231, "pct": 6.9 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 10, "of": 242, "pct": 4.1 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 9, "of": 140, "pct": 6.4 }, "withMx": { "count": 235, "of": 242, "pct": 97.1 } } }, { "key": "50 - 249", "label": "50 - 249", "total": 138, "observed": 138, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 123, "of": 138, "pct": 89.1 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 90, "of": 123, "pct": 73.2 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 16, "of": 123, "pct": 13 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 135, "of": 138, "pct": 97.8 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 0, "of": 138, "pct": 0 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 4, "of": 135, "pct": 3 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 6, "of": 138, "pct": 4.3 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 6, "of": 90, "pct": 6.7 }, "withMx": { "count": 134, "of": 138, "pct": 97.1 } } }, { "key": "2 - 9", "label": "2 - 9", "total": 99, "observed": 99, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 82, "of": 99, "pct": 82.8 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 50, "of": 82, "pct": 61 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 14, "of": 82, "pct": 17.1 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 94, "of": 99, "pct": 94.9 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 2, "of": 99, "pct": 2 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 5, "of": 94, "pct": 5.3 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 3, "of": 99, "pct": 3 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 3, "of": 50, "pct": 6 }, "withMx": { "count": 97, "of": 99, "pct": 98 } } }, { "key": "250 - 999", "label": "250 - 999", "total": 56, "observed": 56, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 54, "of": 56, "pct": 96.4 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 40, "of": 54, "pct": 74.1 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 7, "of": 54, "pct": 13 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 53, "of": 56, "pct": 94.6 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 1, "of": 56, "pct": 1.8 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 5, "of": 53, "pct": 9.4 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 3, "of": 56, "pct": 5.4 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 3, "of": 40, "pct": 7.5 }, "withMx": { "count": 53, "of": 56, "pct": 94.6 } } }, { "key": "1,000 - 9,999", "label": "1,000 - 9,999", "total": 28, "observed": 28, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "10,000+", "label": "10,000+", "total": 2, "observed": 2, "suppressed": true } ], "mxOperator": [ { "key": "microsoft_365", "label": "microsoft 365", "total": 306, "observed": 306, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 283, "of": 306, "pct": 92.5 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 202, "of": 283, "pct": 71.4 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 48, "of": 283, "pct": 17 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 303, "of": 306, "pct": 99 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 3, "of": 306, "pct": 1 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 17, "of": 303, "pct": 5.6 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 15, "of": 306, "pct": 4.9 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 14, "of": 202, "pct": 6.9 }, "withMx": { "count": 306, "of": 306, "pct": 100 } } }, { "key": "unknown", "label": "unknown", "total": 93, "observed": 93, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 87, "of": 93, "pct": 93.5 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 54, "of": 87, "pct": 62.1 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 15, "of": 87, "pct": 17.2 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 91, "of": 93, "pct": 97.8 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 1, "of": 93, "pct": 1.1 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 7, "of": 91, "pct": 7.7 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 3, "of": 93, "pct": 3.2 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 3, "of": 54, "pct": 5.6 }, "withMx": { "count": 93, "of": 93, "pct": 100 } } }, { "key": "google_workspace", "label": "google workspace", "total": 86, "observed": 86, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 74, "of": 86, "pct": 86 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 45, "of": 74, "pct": 60.8 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 11, "of": 74, "pct": 14.9 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 81, "of": 86, "pct": 94.2 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 1, "of": 86, "pct": 1.2 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 1, "of": 81, "pct": 1.2 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 2, "of": 86, "pct": 2.3 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 2, "of": 45, "pct": 4.4 }, "withMx": { "count": 86, "of": 86, "pct": 100 } } }, { "key": "gateway", "label": "gateway", "total": 46, "observed": 46, "suppressed": false, "metrics": { "dmarcAdoption": { "count": 45, "of": 46, "pct": 97.8 }, "dmarcEnforcement": { "count": 33, "of": 45, "pct": 73.3 }, "noAggregateReporting": { "count": 4, "of": 45, "pct": 8.9 }, "spfAdoption": { "count": 46, "of": 46, "pct": 100 }, "multipleSpfRecords": { "count": 0, "of": 46, "pct": 0 }, "spfLookupFailure": { "count": 5, "of": 46, "pct": 10.9 }, "bimiAdoption": { "count": 2, "of": 46, "pct": 4.3 }, "bimiAmongEnforcing": { "count": 1, "of": 33, "pct": 3 }, "withMx": { "count": 46, "of": 46, "pct": 100 } } }, { "key": "no_mx", "label": "no mx", "total": 19, "observed": 19, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "mixed", "label": "mixed", "total": 14, "observed": 14, "suppressed": true }, { "key": "other", "label": "other", "total": 2, "observed": 2, "suppressed": true } ] }, "rankStandardizedByMxOperator": [], "scanner": { "version": "2.0.0", "resolvers": [ "8.8.8.8", "1.1.1.1" ], "mxClassifierVersion": "2026-08-14.2", "mxClassifierSources": { "google": "https://knowledge.workspace.google.com/admin/domains/set-up-mx-records-for-google-workspace", "microsoft": "https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/enterprise/external-domain-name-system-records?view=o365-worldwide" } }, "releaseReview": { "approvedAt": "2026-08-14T20:45:40.732Z", "approvals": [ "sources", "methodology", "charts", "seo", "accessibility", "claims" ] } }